Yeah I wouldn't want leftovers chain pizza cold but a good local place with good home made sauce or fresh crushed tomatoes tastes good cold. Basically if it tastes so good fresh that you have a hard time not eating the whole thing despite not being drunk or high it'll taste good cold (as long as you blot it with paper towel if it's super greasy because cold grease blobs are gross).
Bonus unpopular opinion: I don't like tomato sauce on my pizza. I know some people might say what about a binding agent for the ingredients, melted cheese works great for that
I also don’t usually have tomato sauce anymore. Pesto is so much better. The sauce is where bad pizzas go wrong: soupy, overly sweetened, KoolAde of a sauce is just wrong
I’ll also add the reduced toppings. We have a regional chain of wood-fired pizza that I’m a huge fan of. Over time I realized their ideas could go horribly wrong elsewhere, but they pay more attention to proportions, I went from preferring a deep dish mound of melted cheese, to a crisp flatbread with just the right amount of whatever
Pizza that has been left to cool but then reheated slowly in a pan (start without a lid, add lid towards the end to melt the cheese), until the bottom is crispy and the cheese is melted.. beats both fresh or cold pizza imho.
Sadly it’s the most amount of work out of all three options.
Some pizza is great fridged, but not all pizza. There's a local pizza place in town that makes this cheesy, greasy pizza with a soft thin crust. That pizza is particularly good fridged.
I like both equally. Maybe... I suppose it depends on the type of pizza. Where it came from, what the toppings are, etc. Meat Lovers is better hot, IMO, but a Hawaiian style is a little bit better cold because the pineapple taste better cold. Cold combination matters where I got it, because the crust sometimes doesn't hold up in the fridge and gets soggy AF from the veggies getting wet.
I also ….. but yesterday my ex stopped by and left a pizza from a godawful low-end national chain. I tried having some for lunch and it was just horrible. I hate her for that. /s
My late father once cooked a pizza on the barbecue grill (yes they make a special pan assembly for that), and oddly enough it seemed to taste even better after almost a whole week in the fridge.
Of course after almost a week, we didn't eat it cold right out of the fridge, we put it in the microwave first, but somehow the time it spent in the fridge made it taste even better. 🤷♂️