It's not an illusion. The men that perform this harassment generally know they're wrong and therefore keep it secret.
I don't know anyone who's sexually assaulted/harassed a woman because I'm very open about how that's not fucking okay. If I find out someone has it'll either lead to violence or cutting them out of my life completely
Every man goes to secret fratbro social club meetings. It's on the third Tuesday rotating bi annually every year. We do it at 4am so you don't notice we're gone. It's where we all tell each other our secret darkest sexual assault/rape confessions so everyone can know who we need to cover for.
Why, OP, are you being so toxic in all your answers? Sure there are men who harassed or are still harassing women and every one is one enough. But pointing out that some of us don't know anyone personally who is guilty of doing such isn't downplaying.
Even IF I would say "NOT ALL MEN!1!!" doesn't mean shit. It doesn't mean "yeah, you are exxagerating" or "this problem isn't that big as you try making it"
It's just a "I don't really want to be associated with that kind of male scum." Nothing more, nothing less.
But IF you wanted to say "Distancing in a post is not enough to stop this." you could have said it, instead of trying to drive a wedge.
Do it and try to have a constructive dialog instead, maybe?
Not with those clearly incapable of listening, let alone not centre themselves and make it all about how they aren't part of the problem despite actively being part of the problem
The problem you are creating is driving away the ACTUAL discourse into meta discussions like this and angering those who actually ARE listening in the first place. You are NOT helping the case - at all.
Edit: I just want to make it clear: Your claim isn't true and thus cannot be a healthy start for a deep and honest discussion about harrasment.
You know, when MeToo came out, I thought I'd been lucky because I'd never been harassed.
And then I thought about it, and I remembered:
Walking through the mall and a guy making the "big jugs" gesture at the male friend I was walking with, congratulating my friend on his date (it wasn't a date).
The older guy who tried to pick up noticably-underage me at the town fair, then followed me around, and how I literally had to run into the woods to get away from him.
The kid I went to school with who tried to finger me in the football stands.
The senior manager at a large programming firm who thought it was appropriate (very visibly in his company office) to hang a shadow box with a bunch of little medallions in it. Except when you looked closely at the medallions, you found out that they were actually hooker tags from quite a number of brothels.
The greying mechanic my mom had come over to work on her car while she was at work, who wanted 15-year-old me to kiss him.
The multiple coworkers who deliberately kept making crude sexual jokes, and if you ignore them or join in, they take it as permission to keep going, and if you're uncomfortable or say something they take it as a challenge and escalate, and if you report it you end up getting fired for something else in the next month or so.
Slapping hands away, so many times.
And even in the context of MeToo, I thought I hadn't been harrassed, when in reality I'd just normalized the harassment and ignored it. Because it wasn't that bad, it wasn't 'abuse', it wasn't constant.
But while it may not have been constant, it was persistent. There wasn't a single place that I was ever safe. The carefree town fair, the local shops, school, work, my own home when the mechanic came in to use the bathroom. There's literally no place in my life where intrusive men haven't tried to insert themselves, without invitation, without even asking.
And I look at this meme and it's "every woman knows someone who's been harassed", and I think over my own experience, and that of all my female relatives, and friends, and schoolmates, and coworkers, and I think that meme is wrong.
I think pretty much every woman has been harassed. It's just that, like me, they learned to ignore and then forget these things, because they weren't as bad as the really bad things that have happened to some of the women we know. But - and not discounting the really bad experiences some people I know have had - these experiences were all bad enough.
First of all, I am sorry for what you had to endure. It’s a lot.
Now regarding the post, I encountered very few harassers in my life (my own brother sadly is one of them, and a Texan expat that used to be my friend until, well you know)
I don’t think harassers will spontaneously come out about their « habit ». From what I’ve seen, men know very well what abusive behavior is, but will never admit that they are abusive themselves because it would reveal their own weakness. Men are terrified of looking weak.
About my own mistakes, I’ve never been an harasser (I won’t take a no for a yes) but I have abused a woman once because she never told me « no » nor pushed me back. It was years before #MeToo
I didn’t know she was raised as a Mormon, forbidden to say no to a man.
We spend the night and most of the next day together, mostly talking about books and movies but didn’t « make it ». We mostly kissed and I only went down on her during the night. I had absolutely no clue, and learned about my mistake about 2 years later.
I was devastated.
My point is that there’s a lot of work to do. Men and women still have no clue about what’s the right thing to do.
Fuck, I'm cis-het guy and I hadn't really thought about it until #MeToo, but MeToo.
Hanging out with my girlfriend, her friends & my wife and one of the guy friends grabbed my junk and said that "you have a nice package". I moved away from him, but otherwise, the night just continued as it had been and I went on with my life.
There have been a few other instances, sometimes with men, sometimes with women, but, fuck if that isn't a shitty realization to have come to.
Once, to show her daily experience, my gf at the time (now wife) had me walk far enough in front of her that we didn't appear together, but not so far I wouldn't be able to hear. The amount of catcalls when walking down a city street while dressed non-provactively was fucking ridiculous (it would still be ridiculous if she were 'dressed to impress' to be fair, but I'm trying to illustrate that she wasn't dressed in any way that could 'generously' be interpreted as 'asking for the attention'). I hadn't not believed her before, but seeing it myself was eye opening and made me realize I need to not be in a bubble when I'm out and about.
Anyone who identifies as a guy and says "I've never seen someone getting harassed" ... open your eyes and ears as you walk through the world and see if that's actually true or if you just didn't pay enough attention to notice it. Ask basically any woman you know if they've ever gotten catcalled or had their ass grabbed in public or at what age men in their 40s started sexualizing them; if you have a close enough relationship, I can almost guarantee that they'll say 'yes' to the first couple and 12-14ish for the last one -- and those are direct questions rather than "have you been harassed" which might be more open to self-deception.
Everyone knows it's not ALL men, but I have to imagine that it feels close-a-fucking-nough when you're getting harassed on what feels like a constant basis.
This is well put, shame those who need to hear it most will refuse to listen (to advice like yours, but definitely not to any women they might have in their lives)
Well said, I think OP of the tweet probably wanted to avoid replies from women claiming they hadn't had these experiences (most likely because like you, like me, like so many of us, they internalised it), but I'm with you - I don't know a single woman who has managed to escape harassment (at the very least). From before we even hit puberty, for our entire lives, it's like this background noise, and half the population pretending they don't even hear it feels like a slap in the face.
Well it’s not like they go around advertising that they are harassers and rapists.
The statement also assumes the numbers are equal, but predominant amount of assaults are perpetrated by a minority of people. So you have a small number of abusers who victimize a large amount of people.
Them not advertising it doesn't mean they aren't there, and that if only you cared enough to know the signs or even just listen to and believe women when we literally point them out, you would see them too.
That second part is also factually and statistically simply not true but I honestly don't care enough about educating you to do your research for you.
I think you are missing my point here. “No man seems to know” is precisely because because it’s hidden. It’s not that they don’t know, it’s that they don’t know that they know, because people don’t advertise their acts.
As for statistics, general crime statistics in everyday category point to a minority of people perpetrating them, unless you are saying that this is somehow different from all other behavior.
Thanks for the patronizing instead of “educating”. I’m sure your that will help to actually address the problem.
As much as you want it to be true, not all men associate with rapists. Sorry. I'm as liberal as you get, but you can't be stupid and hateful to one group and call yourself progressive. I've worked hard to be good and stay away from bad people, you can't shit it all away cause I was born the gender you hate
TBF I've known a hand full of men who openly talk about harassing or having harassed women. They just don't see it as harassment, because they think it's "no big deal" or that they "have" to treat women like that.
TW sexual assault:
I was once waiting for a friend when a very drunk man came up to me and started talking. He was babbling about how he likes to fight, and his ex and so on, when he suddenly shouted (direct quote): "I didn't rape her! I just punched her in the gob a few times and she spread her legs all on her own!"
I think that's an extreme case, but not as extreme as one might think.
This right here is the quiet part of the tweet out loud, thank you! 👏👏👏
It's all around all of them (us!) constantly, it just isn't a problem to them, so they "don't see" it (to varying degrees of awareness).
Also jfc what that guy said to you, but as you say not that extreme or even unusual.. 😕
Lol the comment section here is a shitshow. OP had an interesting post that could have prompted a good discussion, but instead went toxic female incel in the comment section and became a laughing joke.
Only this isn't a discussion space, and I'm not here to coddle the feelings of fragile egos of men who are completely incapable of (and entirely unintersted in) actually listening.
Also making the false comparison between an individual woman not giving men who are here for no other reason but whine, the time of day, and a literal bunch of terrorists that is directly responsible for the deaths of hundreds of women and indirectly the deaths of hundreds more, doesn't do you any favours.
Go cry about it someplace else.
This social media platform comment section isn't a discussion space?
No one was asking to be coddled. You jumped down the throat of anyone who shared their opinion.
You will never contribute to the solution of this problem, and not because of your desire to change it, I'm sure you're motivated. But you lack any form of communication skills to engage in meanful conversation. Without that you cannot provide a convincing argument to educate.
You alienate yourself from your audience you wish to address and improve, and without any credibility your contribution is meaningless. Then you become a target for ridicule, which appears to perpetuate your situation as you lash out more.
Communication and meaningful conversation is a powerful tool, and one worth wielding to address topics such as this.
It's a particular kind of weird as a trans person. You go from being largely ignored while out and about to getting looks of disgust to getting catcalled all within the span of a year in my case.
There's a sort of, yay I pass from a distance kind of thing but then it settles in and it becomes yet another thing to try and tune out and hope words are the worst of it. Heaven forbid some guy hollers at you and then stops his truck up ahead cause you said nothing and didn't look his way.
That must be such a strange and overwhelming mix of emotions. I can only imagine it's like when we afab folks hit puberty and suddenly were seen as an object of desire and there's all this unwanted attention that we've also been taught to take as a compliment, it's so confusing.
It is. As someone who got a lot of those messages that were directed at AFAB folks and internalized them it was like putting a critical piece into a puzzle. It's one thing to hear about it and have some insights. It's another to be immersed in it so late in life comparably.
As a cis male, I learned a lot from the book "Everyday Sexism" by Laura Bates. It really opened my eyes to the reality that women deal with on a regular basis, and I hope it's ok to recommend it here.
I knew a harasser that admitted to harassing the girls in our friend group for fun. Fortunately he was afraid of harassing my gf at the time because I called him out on his bullshit. That entire friend group chose him over me.
Men are trash (myself included, im no saint) and I hope my daughter is a lesbian.
Congratulations, you did the bare minimum and then made sure to make the conversation about you and your "effort" for some cookies.
Well I'm all out of cookies to give.
The lesson here is sometimes it's ok, if not mandatory, to just shut up and listen.
The point of the tweet is you absolutely ALL fucking know rapists and harrassers.
Abusers are manipuators, and you are not immune.
But even that excuses too many of you who absolutely witness sexual harassment and other aspects of rape culture regularly and say fuck all.