Mercurygram: a Telegram FOSS fork with Material You themes and additional features
Mercurygram: a Telegram FOSS fork with Material You themes and additional features
Unofficial, FOSS-friendly fork of the original Telegram client for Android - Mercurygram/Mercurygram
Yes this is a Telegram client and yes it will break the Lemmy's downvote world record but I still find this one very nice and "actively" maintained. There are not many good Telegram FOSS forks without Google integrations and similar stuff out there.
You're viewing a single thread.
do any of these forks support E2EE? I don't mean the OG "private chat" thingy that Telegram supports.
I mean like an add-on, the way pidgin had an OTR plugin that enabled private comms over Google's unencrypted XMPP servers.
as a consequence, that would also encrypt everything in the cloud and prevent your chat history being ingested for LLM training and whatnot.
That would require the other user to use the same app as you right? Could be interesting.
At that point why not use a different app that supports E2EE natively?
because Telegram's UI/UX is second to none; possibly iMessage or whatever it's called is close, albeit with way limited functionality. Signal and friends look like a PoC from 2015 in comparison. also the apps, on mobile and on desktop, have a low memory footprint with no bloated electron crap, the cross-device sync is phenomenal and there's the virtually unlimited cloud storage. if an addon could piggyback off of that, that would be spectacular.
however, OP's insight as to this being against ToS is obviously a deal breaker. seeing as how they're adamant about leaving all your shit unencrypted in the cloud I'm looking for other havens, begrudgingly; I've been a user from the early days.
The options are basically:
Matrix if you want a Discord-like experience
XMPP if you want a whatsapp/google talk like experience (both of those are based on XMPP)
Signal if you want hyper-secure chat and don't mind some mild inconveniences in things like registration or desktop apps.
All three support or can support E2EE.
well yeah, just a simple private/public key solution for encrypting chat and cloud. transfer your private key to a forked desktop app and access your encrypted chat history from there as well.
just basic stuff, not something for people running from nation-state actors, but to prevent LLM ingestion and mass surveilance. but OP says that's against Telegram's ToS, so no dice here.
E2EE is prohibited by Telegram's TOS (you can't make any feature that requires users to use your client to access it).
Whoa, they not only won't implement it, but will work on not letting anyone else do it. They're more shady than I thought.
They're not shady. They just don't want to lose the market share and I think if they made Telegram really secure, there'd be even more illegal stuff on it and the government wouldn't like it.
"They're not shady." Begins to describe the shady shit they do
How is it "shady" to not want to lose market share and keep illegal stuff off of it?
You could argue it's "shitty" (perhaps, but it is their servers after all) but I don't find it shady.
How is it "shady" to not want to lose market share and keep illegal stuff off of it?
Market share shouldn't be a concern with encrypted chat. If it is then I don't trust it.
If you're making an encrypted chat, you're going to have illegal things on it. If only the chat owners have the keys then that shouldn't be the server owners concern.
I would strongly recommend
libaxolotl/OMEMO over OTR, far stronger algorithm.