[DM David] From Hommlet to Phandalin, Villages Written as a List of Locations Seem Ready To Run. They Lie
[DM David] From Hommlet to Phandalin, Villages Written as a List of Locations Seem Ready To Run. They Lie
Villages written with nothing more than a list of locations imply that DMs need nothing more to bring adventure. They lie and I’ve fallen for it. I should know better by now. Many starting Dungeons…
Hmmm, I guess I never used boxed sets, but I kind of assumed they gave interaction ideas / details to get the party started so to say. Honestly, if it were me I'd suggest thinking of DMing like collaboratively writing a choose your own adventure story. You sketch out / write some of it in advance, and each session go through one or more of the branching story and then you know where to continue for the next session.
If you're decent, you can easily handle players going off on different paths with some gentle adjustments to the world to get them back on track. If you're good, you can extemporaneously create these new paths and goals to some extent and let the players guide the story.
I think the important part is you need to create and guide a story somehow. Just having an open world with a list of things to potentially do is like a video game, and tends to (in my limited experience playing in this sort of game) lead to boredom in the players. Especially if the DM doesn't know how to do roleplaying vignettes or what and where they fit. Every trip through a town on the way to somewhere else doesn't need a full session of roleplaying the tavern and shops (unless the players angle that way). Every long rest doesn't need to take an hour of play time to work out 3 watches, 3 sets of players standing watch "talking" about ??? (when the players are like, I have nothing to say really), overland travel can just be quick travel if nothing but a random encounter might happen.
Back in the days of boxed sets, I never ran into groups that did a lot of roleplay in a town setting unless it was an adventure module set in town. It was mostly dungeon crawls to get to the big bad and kill him. Hell, I can't really recall dealing with rest or encumbrance back then. Combat positioning was theater of the mind and limiting rules were hand waved away.
That is not meant to sound like good nostalgia. We had fun, but today's resources and rules are light-years away from the eighties.
After all, some DMs boast of players who will enter a strange town and happily spend an evening chatting with folks for just the fun of roleplaying. Such players are a treasure.
I think if someone did this at my game, I'd go take a nap on the couch and have them wake me up when they're done.
I would leave without waking you. Sleep well.
I've always hated clicking through the dialog options just to find the one that will move the plot along. For me, chatting up townspeople is like making me roll perception when the DM already knows there's nothing to find.
I'm already terrible at socializing with real people. Why would I spend my precious free time pretending to socialize with imaginary people?