Reddit blackout: Subreddits to go private on Monday

After Steves AMA really doubt anything will break through that guys ego. Wouldn't surprise me if they just start cleaning house on subs that go longer than the two days.

Sadly, I'm sure they wouldn't have any problem finding more "cooperative" mods to replace them if they did
- Step 1: Remove the people that closed it Step 2: Put new mods in place (probably just gonna be alt admin accounts not labeled as such) Step 3: Profit or some shit like that
- They've done it multiple times in the post so I don't doubt it.

Highly unlikely that this 'protest' will do anything. However I think it will be the point at which a lot of users quit Reddit. Thats the time where Lemmy will make get 20-50k new users.

I think there should be a website that compares the top 5 or so instances and explains the differences between them. Since right now, new users will have no idea which one to join.

Start referring your friends. If you have any.

Instance owners could update the descriptions on https://join-lemmy.org/instances to include a link to a "Who are we" kind of readme.

Ultimately I'm not sure any of the instances will look the same in a month.
Highly unlikely that this ‘protest’ will do anything.

I agree to that. While the common mainstream news are reporting it, two-day drip in activity will hardly put a dent in the monthly analytic.
- Some like r/dndmemes say it is indefinite.

that one time when 16 mods controlling half of Reddit actually worked out in our favor

For those who want to watch it happen: https://reddark.untone.uk/

Wow, 108 of them have already gone. I use Reddit Sync, so I really want this to have an effect, but I've seen how blackouts usually go...
- 160 on Jun 10 at 1240 EST
of course /r/circlejerk is dark lmaooooooo i fucking love that sub so much 🤣

Unfortunately 48 hours probably won’t do anything if they just come back like nothing happened. If the AMA with spez has shown anything it’s that Reddit is not going to back down even with the large protest from the community.

Yeah, the AMA was the final nail in the coffin imo.

Even though I don't think it will have an effect on the decision they took, I do want to see if the admins replace mods or take control of subreddits

Then I hope they wipe their subreddits while they can.
- Pure guess work from me, but I assume reddit could just roll back and restore a nuked sub from backups? Maybe lose a few hours to a days worth of posts?

Ive deleted my Reddit account last evening, when i did read their plans. Lemmy is pretty cool tho, let hope we get more powa soon here :)

Power to the people!

The protest itself won’t have any impact. Two days won’t be enough to alter a single thing. Those that are going to remain dark indefinitely I wouldn’t be surprised if they are taken back by Reddit and assigned another mod. Corporate will win in the end, even if it does turn out to cost them.

Hopefully more subs will follow r/videos lead. They have planned to go offline indefinitely/permanently. Although it's quite likly reddit admins will nuke the mod team and reopen it with new mods.
- I want to hope that if Reddit does end up doing that, it'll be seen and treated like scabs during a strike.
- It was either apple or iPhone that just announced they are going private permanently
That's cool. Let reddit turn into the next Facebook. It will attract the garbage and protect us from that.
The attempts at indefinite blackouts could have more impact than we expect, even if admins intervene and reopen them with new mods. They're doing this very publicly and with overwhelming support from their communities, so the "takeovers" would just make it look even worse for Reddit.

That will not change Reddit's mind about their plans, but it could convince more users to move on to greener pastures (Lemmy or otherwise)
It will at least show the reddit users that don't know anything about it that there is something big going on

I wonder how long it takes for them to boot the current mods and put new ones in?

I give it a day, at least for the 20M+ member subs
As someone that mods on multiple 1m+ subreddits, this is not viable across hundreds of subreddits with tens of active mods per subreddit.

And it's not viable with the userbases either, many of them would go full scorched earth rebellion against the site. Reddit is trying to calm things rather than turn it into a massive thing.

If large quantities of users decide to wreck the site with spam posts there is very little that admins can do. Committed users hell bent on trashing reddit can do so in greater numbers than can be responded to. This occurred when /r/FatPeopleHate got banned (a sub that thoroughly deserved it but hey ho) when a lot of the site went into a rebellion against Ellen Pao. They remember this, and do not want to repeat it.

I totally realize most people are going to disagree with me here but I feel compelled to say that closing the sub for a joke wasn’t a very kind thing to do. We have seen TONS of posts from vulnerable populations talking about how the sub is a source of support and humor in a dark time. Irony and dirtbagism aside, taking away that support without warning was not okay.

You can say I’m being silly, or humorless or reactionary. Whatever. I love the sub and I love this community. But sometimes I come home after dealing with ableism and our nightmare reality all day, and this sub is one of many things that make me feel better. It wasn’t a good feeling to find the sub closed for the sake of irony. Maybe that’s laughable or pathetic. But for me, it’s true.

I don't think that's silly at all. I wasn't aware that some subs were closing only as a joke/ironically, which is pretty shitty if that's the case. Most communities I was a part of are participating in the blackout for legitimate reasons. Hopefully those communities can be rebuilt here, but I understand that's not ideal and can take time. Which sub are you referring to, if I may ask?