Cheap proton batteries compete with lithium on energy density
Cheap proton batteries compete with lithium on energy density
edit I am an idiot, who uploaded the image link as the URL. The original source should now be accessible
RMIT engineers say they've tripled the energy density of cheap, rechargeable, recyclable proton flow batteries, which can now challenge commercially available lithium-ion batteries for capacity with a specific energy density of 245 Wh/kg.
Battery tech exists in a variety of stages. We have been using Li-ion for ages but there are two technologies coming out this year and next which are very much real (from CATL the worlds leader in battery sales) one of which you can buy today.
You can buy Sodium Ion batteries already, search for it on aliexpress and you'll see the cells are for sale and BYD is already selling cars with it in. Its similar power in weight and density as Li-ion but it doesn't catch on fire and its a lot more environmentally friendly. Its good a chance of being the main battery used for home/grid storage and cars and other big battery uses, it also lasts a lot of cycles something like 6000-8000 so it will work for decades and its cheap at $50/KWH (li-ion is more like $130).
The other type is a Li-ion advancement into solid state that is due next year and it doubles the power density. That is probably going to end up in laptops and phones and some high end cars with massive range or smaller/lighter batteries where the increased cost for power density is worth it. Not yet at commercial volumes it is well past the theoretical stage however and very much something that can be manufactured already.
All this battery tech in the lab might very well be in the mix in the future but we don't need them to pan out with Sodium Ion filling that space and quite cheaply due to the abundance of salt. I think for grid storage reflux batteries might see a resurgence for their versatility but it remains to be seen if they become price competitive. Li-ion as we use today is very soon to be replaced thankfully.
Found a good video article on Na-Ion battery technology; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQE56ksVBB4
So according to that article Na-Ion energy density is comparable to the LFP type of Li-Ion battery. That's about 20% lower than the more common types you see in consumer products and EVs. LFP has much longer cycle life and lower fire hazard so it's used where weight and space are less of a concern. However it still has the same cost and materials issues.
Na-Ion is well poised to replace LFP. The advantage is lower cost and more environmentally friendly materials. Unfortunately Na-Ion is not inline to replace the higher energy density types. As it becomes more widely adopted it may improve to the point where it can so there's hope for it.
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/watch?v=RQE56ksVBB4
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
You can buy Sodium Ion batteries already,
You see a lot of stories about the next great battery tech. I've been seeing them for years, but still Li-Ion is the ubiquitous tech.
Even if energy density is only comparable, a battery with lower fire hazard and increased longevity is sorely needed. Li-Ion batteries simply wear out too fast. Considering the replacement cost (especially for EV applications), its a huge advantage for consumers. Then there's a bonus of it being cheaper and more environmentally neutral which is also a big deal.
Of all the proclamations of a better battery, Na-Ion sounds like it might actually be a reality. That would make me happy to be rid of Li-Ion batteries once and for all. The only advantage they have is high energy density, they're a fail on every other front.
it also lasts a lot of cycles something like 6000-8000 so it will work for decades
Not good enough for the next 10 years.
Energy density and charging speed must, and will, improve by much more.
"you don't need lithium or any other exotic metals"
This is really good news.
Lithium isn't exactly exotic, it's the third most common element in the universe.
Please sir, may I have the sauce?
I've edited the post, thankfully someone beat me to replying so you weren't left hanging. My apologies!
Does this exist as a consumer product yet?
This is a research paper, so it's gonna be at least a couple of years until ot could be seen in products. However the battery uses hydrogen, it's effectively an alternative to fuel cells, so the use case would be in vehicles rather than yout phone. That being said, hydrogen fuel infrastructure is almost non-existent right now.
Is the infrastructure relevant though? As I understand it, the battery is charged by splitting water (H2O) into Oxygen and Hydrogen atoms (instead of H2 molecules, hence the name proton battery) and instead of compressing and cooling it, having a solid structure in which to store the protons. When drawing energy from the battery the opposite process takes place. So basically it is both an electrolyser when charging and a classic fuel cell when discharging with the storage of hydrogen (protons) being integrated in the same battery through a porous solid (mainly carbon). To quote from the article: >It looks like more of a battery competitor than a fuel cell competitor, though.
Next to the advantages they cite (energy and power density, abundant and environmentally unproblematic materials, recyclability, not explosive) I do wonder about the density in terms of volume. If they are bigger in size, they could constitute a better solution for big energy storages within the grid or at home, where now many are using lithium ion batteries.
You should definitely read the linked article. You're right about it being for your car, not your phone, but seriously, read the article.
Others downvote you and say "read the article", but not giving arguments.
I read the article and it is not clear what is the advantage... looks like less pressure is needed than other types of hidrogen cells, but there are no details.
I agree with you, don't hold your breath for this. All details would be in first sentence if there was any chance of this becoming reality.
And you basically have 2 options for hydrogen production: oil consuming and GG-emitting steam reformation, or energy intensive electrolysis of water, unless there's another i don't know
The battery uses dark matter, it's effectively an alternative to nuclear fusion, so the use case would be in space stations rather than yout phazer set to stun.
From what the article said, most definitely not. But, it doesn't look very complex in terms of scaling / manufcaturing it and they say they want to get it to market quickly.
Sadmy, this is going to disappear... Its always the same with good things
I'm going to let you in on a little secret.
They don't disappear because of some conspiracy.
They disappear because they don't do what they claim to. Or they only perform that way in a small scale on a lab bench. Or they are too expensive. Or vastly many other reasons.
I think this xkcd statement is equivalent enough: when someone says that they cured cancer in a petri dish, keep in mind that so does a hand gun.
Some shady holding company is going to buy the patent for it and sit on it forever while the rest of humanity continues to pillage underdeveloped nations for their lithium.
I'm sorry, but there is simply no way that anyone can have so little greed as to prefer to exercise their sociopathy rather than become the richest person on earth (where they can harm people much more effectively).
The reason these things don't materialize is because they weren't never there in the first place.
I was actually just watching a 60 minutes episode on YouTube the other day about a massive, fully green, generations long mining source of lithium in SoCal. It'll be able to supply all of the lithium needed for yearly domestic American EV sales and because it's so close to home, prices for these massive battery packs should fall off precipitously.
buy the patent for it and sit on it forever
I.have seen this happening, but I don't believe that it can happen with this one. Broad usage, very different usecases seem possible.