AMD vs Nvidia
AMD vs Nvidia
I am going to buy a new graphics card and can't choose between Nvidia and AMD. I know that Nvidia has bad reputation in Linux community but how really it works? And I heard recently their drivers got better. What can you recommend?
P. S. I don't want any proprietary drivers (so I am talking about Nouveau or any other FOSS Nvidia driver if it exists)
You're viewing a single thread.
AMD. Unless you need blender.
Edit: to make my point clear. To some religiose like venting below.
Nothing I said says don't use amd on blender.
I said AMD unless you need blender. IE for everything but blender use AMD for blender their is a need to consider both.
As others have pointed out. The software development history of blender means for certain tasks nvidia is much faster. And will be for the foreseeable future.
If you need blender then the choice is more complex then just amd.
A do not really do anything gpu intensive other then blender. So for me nvidia even with their drivers makes sense.
I am AMD and use Blender just fine. What do you mean?
Cuda and optix are anecdotally three times faster at rendering than any amd solution.
That doesn’t mean amd doesn’t perform well though, its personal preference on how much that time saving is worth it.
AMD-HIP works just great for me.
"Works great" and "Could work 3x faster" matter to a lot of people.
Well then you're just nagging about hardware, which isn't the issue being spouted on here. Blender works with AMD hardware just great, which OP was saying is not the case.
Blender works with AMD hardware just great
No it doesn't. That's our point. It works 30% as fast as its competition. That's not "working just great"...it's working slowly and like shit. The whole damn point of a GPU is to accelerate that work. The work that your AMD-HIP is doing in blender, could take an hour, and the NVidia would pump it out in 20 minutes.
You're bitching about hardware capabilities. Read OP's comment and stop showing up just to comment if you can't provide anything constructive except whining pedantry.
Nobody is bitching. Rage less. My constructive point is that NVidia is a better option. NVidia's CUDA stack is software - and unfortunately for us, that means it's also paired with their hardware.
Many people care if choosing something is going to hobble their workflow. In this point, if you're using Blender, choosing AMD is going to hobble your productivity. I'm just stating facts.
Is your information applicable to the nouveau drivers? I’d understood they’re many years behind in performance and capability but blender has never been in my use case.
Cuda is superior for rendering heavy scenes. You can use AMD/Intel/integrated just fine, but it'll be slower.
There are a lot of workflows where that doesn't matter (like using Eevee, or designing parts for 3D print).
Blender supports cuda for much of its gpu work. It will work with amd. And there are projects allowing gpu rendering via amd. But they are (and have been for a while) a long way behind the cuda stuff.
For major rendering projects nvidia is still the fastest set up to use.