Skip Navigation
lovestha LovesTha🦒 @mtgjudge.social

Judge from Melbourne.

First played 1994 Playing constantly since Mirrodin Prerelease (2003) Judging since 2005? L2 since 2008? Judged some international GPs, PTs, and Worlds. (NZ, Singapore, Malaysia, Japan, USA)

Creator of this here instance, but please use the @admin account for all official things.

Posts 0
Comments 42
On the Future of Commander (WotC taking over management of the format, considering adding more concrete power level rankings)
  • @luxyr42 @mike It gives a ceiling, not a floor or average power level.

    Treating such system as not informing deck building is ignoring human behaviour. People will avoid including a single card from a higher tier than they enjoy playing. Unless it is worth bringing up in Rule 0 conversations and explaining that it isn't a good way to think about this deck in particular.

    And players will treat a single card from +1 tier more kindly than they will treat a tier 1 deck including a tier 4 card.

  • Phil Foglio has launched a Kickstarter for Magic tokens
  • @mike @MysticKetchup original goal isn't really an important number. It's just a number that below there they are better off not doing it. 30k is a useful amount of money, but plenty ends up at the printers and not in Phil's pocket.

  • Commander Banned and Restricted Announcement – September 23, 2024
  • @nexguy @MysticKetchup That is valid for insular play groups, it doesn't work at conventions. And only partially works at stores, they can be a mixed bag.

  • Commander Banned and Restricted Announcement – September 23, 2024
  • @Evu @mike I know of unicorn decks that sol ring is bad in, but they are so unusual they only demonstrate the truth.

  • The Sliver Kids: How Two Nobodies Broke the Pro Tour
  • @MysticKetchup best PT ever.

    It gave a lot of people hope of being great

  • The Nadu Situation – Mark Rosewater on Tumblr
  • @Semjaza At least there the were trying to straight nerf. And going from +1/+1 to +1/-1 is a nerf, just not on *that* card

  • The Nadu Situation – Mark Rosewater on Tumblr
  • @Semjaza the history of untested changes breaking is long. Skullclamp is another example

  • The Nadu Situation – Mark Rosewater on Tumblr
  • @Spzi opperating in fear of a too strong card leads to boring sets. But it is the right way to do the changes that don't get tested.

  • The Nadu Situation – Mark Rosewater on Tumblr
  • @andrew @Evu any process will have changes that occur without testing. Unless the process is willing to miss shipping dates.

    I think the design crime with Nadu was the fear of shipping a bad card after nerfing the card. Not realising the modification was risky is something professionals should know: novel abilities are risky.

  • August 26, 2024, Banned and Restricted Announcement
  • @meant2live218 @MysticKetchup some of the Mirrodin block bans were similarly wide sweeping, but had to hit more cards in each deck.

  • August 26, 2024, Banned and Restricted Announcement
  • @morphballganon @Evu does it? They always ban after a deck is turning people off the format. So there is downside to being slow to act.

    Does a broken deck drive enough people to crack packs to find the broken card to play it? That is questionable.

  • Announcing the Magic Spotlight Series
  • @MysticKetchup hopefully this is a small scale trial.

  • Maro explains why Mystery Booster 2 is limited to conventions
  • @MysticKetchup myster boosters show up at conventions that aren't strongly linked to WotC, the OP may have hope.

  • Mystery Booster 2 bringing some previously digital-only cards to paper (Twitter)
  • @f4f4f4f4f4f4f4f4 @MysticKetchup so everywhere ;)

    NB: sealed events also exist.

    MB1 events are very popular. Very fun to play, very fun to judge.

  • Good Morning Magic: How We Pulled Off Mystery Booster 2! What Cards Can You Expect?
  • @f4f4f4f4f4f4f4f4 @MysticKetchup be patient, MB1 is very available at conventions currently, the same is probably going to be true here.

    Or at least it is in Australia, hopefully that is true elsewhere.

  • How did your prerelease go?
  • @MysticKetchup I've always cracked into one pool and built from there. But then the bulk I've done were pre prerelease kits.

  • How did your prerelease go?
  • @MysticKetchup um, 2hg is one card pool for the team, you don't really on open cards individually.

  • How did your prerelease go?
  • @MysticKetchup @Semjaza 2HG is awesome, but random partner is definitely a mixed bag, you never know how it is going to go.

    Hopefully not paired up with someone that is anal about ending the day with perfectly equal value split of the cards that were opened.

  • For the limited players out there - how'd your opinion on Play Boosters settle out?
  • @prodigalsorcerer LGS will use them as prize packs to have cheaper events. It's shit but it will happen

  • For the limited players out there - how'd your opinion on Play Boosters settle out?
  • @prodigalsorcerer @ech Except WotC keep replacing the empty booster slot with more new types of booster, so the less SKUs aspect is failing.