I think the college was a bit too much. It felt like a dystopia. Not sure if it was meant to be a satire. If they wanted to make it look funny, they failed.

I had to think of Buffy too. Maybe it was too early for a musical, but I enjoyed it nevertheless. Especially that Spock was the first to sing. And in the last song he was the first to act normal which was very Spock-like. I think the characters came through in the songs.