Skip Navigation
Corgana Corgana @startrek.website

/r/StarTrek founder and primary steward from 2008-2021

Currently on the board of directors for StarTrek.website

Posts 96
Comments 1.3K
Is Star Wars's treatment of droids and their agency/sentience defensible? How do you think it compares to Star Trek?
  • In Star Wars the droids seem pretty ok with their situation as servants. I suppose you could describe Zora in Discovery similarly, but I'm struggling to think of other examples in Trek.

  • Film Discussion | Star Trek: Section 31
  • What are you going to do a 360 kickflip over? Water?

  • Who says S31 gets to have all the fun?
  • LOL is this OC? Nicely done.

  • "But when the phone inside her ribcage rings, it's not for me."
  • Correct! Teenage Mutant Binja Gurtles.

  • Thank you Microsoft, for the final push
  • Bitwarden

    Do you mean Bitdefender (the antivirus)? Bitwarden is free.

    Before anyone well ackhuallys me yes, there is a very cheap $0.80/mo plan if you want an authenticator.

  • Why does the Terran Empire use the Hunger Games to choose a new emperor and how is one chosen as a competitor?
  • That sidesteps the question of why all of these comically evil people are okay with using this arbitrary contest to determine succession, instead of the usual route of organically murdering each other until someone emerges who is good enough at disposing of potential assassins that they keep the throne for a while?

    I'm saying they're not ok with it, but they are trapped in the current system. It's like, an allegory, maaan.

    I didn’t watch the movie, so I’m probably missing something. Did Georgiou also have to deal with a bunch of normal assassination plots after officially gaining the throne? Or are we to assume that by virtue of winning this contest, she is widely seen as too dangerous for anyone to attempt to usurp?

    Sort of the latter, which is kind of the central plot device.

  • In which I post a graph showing some impact of disinformation on Lemmy, a propagandist disagrees, and someone else summons mods and gets the whole thing removed
  • Can you explain more about your data methodology? Like how did you scrape it? Specifically I'm curious which instances were and weren't included in your study.

  • Why does the Terran Empire use the Hunger Games to choose a new emperor and how is one chosen as a competitor?
  • I'm hesitant to give the Section 31 writers this much credit, but a recurring theme from Star Trek (especially since TNG), is the notion that people are a product of the cultures they come from, and asks the question of if they can grow beyond it.

    This move showed us that Terran empire causes suffering for everyone, even for the top leaders. The system is working for nobody and yet they are all stuck within it. The system of abusing children to choose a new leader seems engineered to make sure that nobody can escape.

    Georgiou, somehow, escaped. And now she's (in her own words) "a monster with a conscious (ie: useless)" in a system that has no need for monsters. She felt useless to change the empire, and useless to do anything once she found it no longer surrounding her.

  • Film Discussion | Star Trek: Section 31
  • That was the best Syfy-channel-pilot-for-a-show-that-ultimatley-didn't-get-picked-up-from-2002 that I've ever seen.

  • "Section 31" early review round-up
  • implies the Federation of TNG is a naive facade

    Man, is there anything more 90s scifi than this concept?

  • Welcome Redditors from the thread earlier today!
  • Reddit mods have less power to remove unwanted speech than Lemmy admins do. If you are upset because mods would not let you say something in their communities, Lemmy is not going to be more accommodating for that.

  • The Stars of Star Trek: Section 31 Know Why You're Nervous About the Movie
  • inb4 someone on lemmy says a single piece of media they haven't even seen is responsible for "shitting all over the entire franchise"

    EDIT: nvm

  • The Stars of Star Trek: Section 31 Know Why You're Nervous About the Movie
  • Villains who's engineered virus forced the Dominion to the negotiating table... just saying.

    "Good and evil isn't as black and white as TNG portrayed it" is kinda DS9's whole deal.

  • The Official Philippa Georgiou backstory from the Star Trek YouTube channel
  • I secretly wrote "star wars" in sharpie on the undercarriage of my 2002 hyundai elantra and would you believe it to my eye it looks no different whatsoever

  • CNET: Fed Up With Instagram? How to Move Your Photos to Pixelfed
  • What bugs have you encountered lately? I've been playing around with it (only a couple of days now) and it's overall been very smooth experience for me.

  • The Official Philippa Georgiou backstory from the Star Trek YouTube channel

    6

    OK Go's latest music video using 64 smartphones. Pretty cool!

    3
    I finished watching DS9... again.
  • This hits hard. Is it your OC?

  • This Aged Well
  • Eh, if an instance allows trolls, then that instance typically gets defederated from very quickly (at least it does on my instance). The only reason it is an issue now is that two of the big three instances (.world and .ml) have very lax moderation standards. If the lemmy-verse grows to the size of Reddit, then two lax instances won't be as big of an issue.

  • If you begin the Voyager episode "Spirit Folk" at exactly 11:49:35 on New Year's eve, Ensign Harry Kim will kiss a cow as the clock strikes midnight.

    13

    "An all-powerful space frog"

    11
    arstechnica.com We’re about to fly a spacecraft into the Sun for the first time

    “Quite simply, we want to find the birthplace of the solar wind.”…

    We’re about to fly a spacecraft into the Sun for the first time
    4

    When discussing the plural name for the group of beings with different faces that are The Doctor, is it proper to say "The Doctors", "Doctors Who" or...?

    Asking for a friend

    11

    A new interview with William Shatner from the Roddenberry Archive.

    4

    TIL Connor Trinneer & Dominic Keating have a podcast called "The D-Con Chamber". Here they are interviewing Nana Visitor on her new book!

    5
    www.mcsweeneys.net The Starfleet Gazette Will Not Be Endorsing a Candidate for President of the United Federation of Planets

    “After the Washington Post announced it would not endorse a presidential candidate in this year’s election or in the future, its billionaire owner ...

    The Starfleet Gazette Will Not Be Endorsing a Candidate for President of the United Federation of Planets

    "Sure, The Borg have been a bit of a problem. Their tendency toward mass assimilation and the stripping of individuality and personal freedom doesn’t exactly jibe with our idea of what makes a great leader. But let’s be honest. Kathryn Janeway hasn’t been perfect."

    8

    The late Teri Garr as Roberta Lincoln in "Assignment: Earth"

    3

    NYCC exclusive new Lower Decks clip

    2

    Lower Decks Season 5 Official Trailer!

    25
    www.theverge.com Reddit is making sitewide protests basically impossible

    It’s going to be a lot harder to pull off massive protests.

    Reddit is making sitewide protests basically impossible

    I quit as the top mod of /r/StarTrek in 2021 in protest against Reddit's platforming of vaccine disinformation subreddits. Then in 2023 during the API protest, myself and several of the remaining mods (including mods from /r/Risa and /r/DaystromInstitute) started StarTrek.website.

    The consensus I've seen on Lemmy has been largely "we don't need to spread the word about our open platforms because Reddit will do something stupid again and there will be another protest and Lemmy will be promoted there". So I hope we can take this as a lesson that we can't rely on platforms being shitty in order to switch society over to open standards. We need to do our best to make Lemmy/Mbin/Piefed good as well as known.

    11

    anyone else agree this episode had no right to be as scary at it was

    8

    We need to get to the bottom of it!

    5

    Can anyone help explain "Dot and Bubble" to me? (spoilers obv)

    For most of this episode I thought it was a good (if a bit on-the-nose) commentary about our societal distraction sickness and everyone living literally in a bubble. The hero was someone who literally able to walk on his own two legs, etc. But once they went underground everything kind of went loopy?

    Where did the slug monsters come from? The idea that they came from "outside the (city's) bubble" kind of reinforced the idea that it's dangerous to hide from what's scary. But then we see the homeworld was also eaten destroyed by the same slug-monsters? If the slugs are controlled or created by the dots, are we meant to understand that the people of the home world are similarly walking around in bubbles? If so, then why does Finetime exist? The whole premise of an off-world "perfect" colony seemed to imply they were providing some service to the home-worlders beyond their 2 hours of "work". Why would a society of people living in bubbles send their youth to a faraway planet?

    Then we see that the dots are capable of quickly killing the inhabitants. So where did the slug monsters come from? Why did the dots not just kill zippoty zop? Were the slugs obeying the dots alphabetical order parameters? Were they created by the dots?

    At this point I was like "whatever it's Doctor Who, the plots are never as consistent as the vibes!" But then the vibes changed completely when it's revealed everyone is racist?!

    My best guess is that this is some bungled way of comparing the people of Finetime to our modern social problem with radicalization on social media, like "look beyond yourself man" but that feels a bit of a stretch. I feel like I'm missing something big here!

    2

    My favorite holiday

    17

    Theory: The EMH in "Academy" is going to be the copy from "Living Witness"

    Until Disco S3, "Living witness" was the furthest future we had seen in Star Trek. But Academy takes place after Discovery. At the end of "Living Witness" the Doctor is described as heading towards Earth.

    Assuming the burn didn't get them, it's entirely possible two EMHs are surviving in Discovery's time. I think it would be a fun twist if it wasn't the EMH we expect!

    8

    What are the biggest red flags when talking with a Trek "fan"?

    96

    The "Friendship is Universal" poster from SDCC

    This was mentioned elsewhere but I thought it was cool enough to deserve it's own post. The artist is Dusty Abell and they are selling copies on their website here: https://www.dustyabell.com/products/star-trek-doctor-who-friendship-is-universal-print

    21