Obviously the genocide the government of Israel is committing right now is horrific, but this begs the question: does any colonially-established and colonizer-ruled country have the right to exist? Like the USA? Canada? Australia?
The US probably does not have the right to exist, not the way it was taken. Rectifying that today is an issue of listening to the people who were here first. The Land Back movement is how the country begins reconciling. Israels future, like The USs future should be paved with large amounts of input from the people who were there before the colonizers were.
I dont think the US has the right to exist but I also know Land Back doesn't simply remove the US from existence and the descendents of colonizers aren't going to be exiled. In much this same way I actually agree that Israel doesn't have the right to exist. It doesn't mean I inherently want them gone, it simply means they had no right to take their nation the way they did and they should be listening to the Palestinians, not warring against them. Saying things like Israel does have the right to exist minimizes things like the Nakba and many other horrific acts. These are not acceptable ways to establish countries in modern times, and the world agrees or no one would be trying to stop Russia right now.
They don't. The genocide and theft of land of their indigenous populations mostly happened less than 150 years ago. That land should be returned to indigenous sovereignty.
How that decolonization should proceed is a question not for the colonizers or their descendents to answer, but the indigenous tribes themselves.
Glad you ask. They don’t.
Uh, why doesn't it?
Because it’s a fascist, Western settler-colonial state that is committing genocide as we speak, and has been ethnically cleansing the indigenous peoples for the last eighty or so years.
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free. From the sea to the river, Palestine will live forever.
Just like for the past 70 years
Idk, Palestine doesn't have a right to exist. In truth no state deserves to exist.
I hope the Palestinian people are okay.
(Isn't the inverse of the statement kinda shitty to hear?)
I don't believe that states should exist but especially not apartheid ethnostates. The 2-state solution wasn't a solution but even then the Palestinian people (both Palestinian Jews and Arabs) were trying to figure out how to navigate the influx of foreign people as best as possible, and large strides were made. That was until the Nakba of course. It's now been over 70 years of Nakba and they say the intifada is unjustified.
