Editorial: Sydney’s gay community is rightly hurt and angry. Police should not march in this year’s Mardi Gras
Editorial: Sydney’s gay community is rightly hurt and angry. Police should not march in this year’s Mardi Gras
Journeys towards justice and equality tend to involve two steps forward and one step back. We are at such a moment in Sydney.
I haven't been following it super-closely, but this reads like the SMH is trying to drum up homophobic controversy where there wasn't any.
My understanding was that the murders were commited by a spurned lover (who happened to be a Police Officer) as opposed to some systemic homophobia within the NSW Police that led to the murders.
No doubt the NSW Police could be more receptive in general, but I don't know if they'd have treated the case any differently if it was a heterosexual officer who was spurned and committed murder - probably more of an indictment on the awfulness of the force than any particularly political or social bent.
I'm not a member of the gay community at all, but I'm struggling to understand this decision.
It's not "the police" that did this - it's an ex boyfriend who also happens to be a copper. I don't believe there's any insinuation that the NSW police haven't done their jobs properly investigating the murders (someone please feel free to correct me if I've got this wrong), so why ask them not be inclusive by marching this year?
If a bricklayer murdered his ex boyfriend and their new lover the same way, would they ask all brickies (or tradies) to not march too? Inclusion is as much about not tarring everyone with the same brush as it is about tolerance and acceptance, and I feel the gay community could be making a misstep here.
Again, I'm not a member of the gay community, so I definitely can't know what people who are, are feeling about this. Just observing that, from the outside, their anger and distress appear to be misdirected in this particular instance.
Brickies and tradies don't have a history of murdering members of the community the way the cops do - especially in nsw.
Besides, a tradie rarely marches AS a tradie. They march as themselves. Cops are really the only ones who constantly insist they must march as their occupation.
I can see your points but, based on the reporting so far, it seems the accused didn't murder them because he's an institutionally intolerant cop, did he? It seems it had nothing to do with the uniform he wore for a job.
Also, I'm not at all saying the NSW police don't have a shocking history of how terribly they've treated this particular community. But isn't the purpose of the cops marching in uniform in the parade to demonstrate their willingness to change, starting with a public display of tolerance and inclusion?
Like I said before, I can't honestly know how the community feels about all this. I'm just confused as to why they're aiming their anger at the cops, when this seems to be anything other than a hate crime perpetrated by the police themselves.
It's not solely about the murder; the NSW Police were already unpopular participants. Homosexuality was illegal within the lifetime of many people attending Mardi Gras and the police were the ones enforcing that. They are still seen as the enemy by some and events like this do nothing to improve that image.
I read “I’m not part of the gay community” and I knew exactly what I would read next, just as I’ve read 1000 times before.
I’m so tired of reading this kind of drivel, taking the time to lay out all the history and facts, only to have it fall on deaf ears.
If you actually cared you’d do some research before posting.
My original comment was pretty clear on the fact that I was trying to understand an alternate perspective. Not history. History tells me about events - it doesn't help me understand why those events make people feel a certain way.
But, by all means, feel free to continue playing the exasperated victim card, and making assumptions about the other person in the conversation.
At least that way, you get to keep blaming everyone else for not making the effort to understand, rather than - you know - actually taking the time to help them understand.
Open minds require open minds.
Realistically police shouldn’t march at all in the Mardi Gras on any year.
How the 78ers tolerate it I have no idea.
Also the SMH can hardly claim any moral high ground here.
I’m definitely lacking some history here (read through the article of course) but my instinct is that it would be best to allow them to continue marching provided those marching have not themselves committed these acts. Perhaps it needs a reframing: the NSW Police segment of the march should not be about bringing positive publicity to the force as a whole, but to celebrate those in the force who are part of the community and make them feel welcome.
Nah. What the police did back in the early days… they are lucky they arnt egged on site for showing up in uniform.
Police don’t have to be there. It’s not about them.
What does “ACAB” mean?
Its literal meaning is all cops are bastards.
In the context of my reply to your previous comment I used it in the sense that the editorial was not arguing that the police should not participate because of the criminal act of 'one bad apple' but neither do the editors call for a permananet ban on police participating in future Mardi Gras.
All Cats Are Beautiful
One bad apple etc… ?
...spoils the bunch?
No, but it's also not ACAB.