Proposed California bill targets electric bicycle speed

I've been tracking this bill since it was first proposed, and the author never got back to me on exactly what is within the scope of the bill. The relevant part of the bill reads:

(e) A person shall not sell a product or device that can modify the speed capability of an electric bicycle such that it no longer meets the definition of an electric bicycle under subdivision (a) of Section 312.5.

For example, would a generic serial programmer device fall within the definition of such a "product or device"? How about software that is used with that device to modify the top speed of a specific ebike model? Common sense would say "no" to the first, and "maybe?" to the second.

But we can look to the author's own comments before the Assembly Transportation Committee:

According to the author, “AB 1774 will ban the sale of electric bicycle (e-bike) speed modification devices (i.e. tuning kits) in California. These devices modify e-bikes far beyond the legal definition of an e-bike in State Vehicle Code.

But the committee staff already see the obvious flaw:

While this bill would prohibit the sale of devices that allow an e-bike to go beyond the speed permitted by law, many e-bikes can be modified to bypass the speed limiter by reprogramming the bicycle. The limiter can be tricked by changing the tire size on the panel on the bicycle. Other e-bikes, like the Super 73, allow you to change the speed of the bicycle using an app that comes with the e-bike.

I would hazard a guess that ebikes manufacturers might start to do the same trick that e-motorbikes do, which is a wire that -- if severed by the owner -- would disable the speed governor.

As is somewhat typical now in the Legislature, these bills written against ebikes tend to come from SoCal, ostensibly because ebikes are an exceedingly popular alternative to driving on congested roads. What bothers me is that these representatives are not taking in the whole reality, which the committee staff report kindly summarized:

• Ebikes are outselling electric automobiles in the USA, by double digit percentages
• Ebike injuries are up, although the LA Times reported it as the low three digits in a 2023 article
• The best way to increase safety for all cyclists is through sheer numbers: more cyclists

Given that reality, legislative effort apparently isn't following evidence but rather towards clumsy distractions that emulate a "tough on ebike" stance, as bizarre as that sounds.