EU condemns Hamas for using 'hospitals as human shields', urges Israeli restraint
EU condemns Hamas for using 'hospitals as human shields', urges Israeli restraint
The European Union on Sunday condemned Hamas for using "hospitals and civilians as human shields" in Gaza, while also urging Israel to show "maximum restraint" to protect civilians.
You're viewing a single thread.
Hamas and the Gaza Health ministry have invited the international community to check this themselves and have apparently provided tours and proof from long ago that that AlShifa hospital has nothing underneath it. The company constructing the Indonesian hospital also denied that any tunnels were underneath and debunked the video of Osrael claiming there is a tunnel entrance there. The EU should check first. There isn't much evidence for tunnels under hospitals and almost all Israel "evidence" provided is such low quality. Not sure how "smart" they are when any 14 year old with a shred of knowledge on using audio editors would be able to tell that the phone call was patched up together from two unrelated ones.
What phone call are you talking about? There was a call relating to the explosion at al Ahli hospital where some people claimed the audio was edited but the only reasoning they had was that one speaker was in one channel and the other speaker in the other channel. That is exactly what you would expect from a wiretap though - the signal for the two speakers is not present in the same wire at the same time, so it needs to be assembled from two separate data sources.
what you would expect from a wiretap though
Source? I don't really know how wiretaps work.
That audio call has been criticized for all sorts of problems. The dialect, the audio put together, the vagueness of the discussion, the fact that the two people sound like two neighbours chatting and not two vetted resistance fighters, etc.
Another example is Israel's most recent claim that the hospital (Al Shifa this time) refused to receive fuel. The phone call is only a few seconds long, the word "fuel" is never mentioned in it, and as an Arabic speaker, I recognized immediately that they were arguing about the "amount" and not the fuel itself. Yet the IDF have published this as "evidence" that the hospital is refusing the fuel delivery, allowing more babies to die. I think it's quite laughable. Turned out later that the IDF promised 2k liters, then decided to send only 300 liters, which would have powered the hospital for half an hour.... totally ignoring that the main issue is that people are being sniped inside the hospital itself, and the yard is filling up with dead and decomposing bodies, some shot for simply stepping foot outside.
I've considered writing about this at more length. I think the Israeli propaganda machine has the quality you would expect from a hobbyist, yet with high aspirations.
The quality and absurdity of IDF propaganda recently gives the impression they don't take it seriously either. It used to be pretty convincing, but I think they're at the point where everyone running the show is an extremist who can't consider the outside perspective. So it becomes this schizophrenic thing where the propaganda is directed at a hypothetical viewer they've envisioned who doesn't really exist. Some of the stuff showing up on my YouTube is straight up uncanny valley weirdness.
Also if everything the IDF is promoting here are the true facts of the situation it still doesn't justify their actions to the world. The number of people who are finally realizing this is at least a good thing. The response to ceasefire protests from the Israel propaganda machine shares the schizophrenic tone with some of the propaganda as well, to the point where they're calling Jewish groups non-Jews and equating peace with anti-Semitism.
I haven't been following the bullshit said by the IDF, but if they're claiming tunnels as the main reason for bombing hospitals, that's ghoulish. They can easily say that Hamas fired rockets from the roof or that they stored weapons amongst patients, and it would be hard to disprove those claims. Don't find evidence of rockets on the roof? Hamas cleaned up the evidence. Don't find evidence of weapons in the hospitals? They moved them. Tunnels aren't like that. Even if sealed off or destroyed, they'll be physical evidence that's hard to get rid of. I guess the typical excuses just weren't cutting it. Even if half the patients were Hamas militants, there's still a ton of innocent people.