Skip Navigation

Elon Musk says he withheld Starlink over Crimea to avoid escalation

www.bbc.com Elon Musk says he withheld Starlink over Crimea to avoid escalation

A senior Ukrainian official says this enabled Russian attacks and accuses him of "committing evil".

Elon Musk says he withheld Starlink over Crimea to avoid escalation

A senior Ukrainian official says this enabled Russian attacks and accuses him of "committing evil".

10
10 comments
  • Musk helping Russia by disabling critical infrastructure Ukraine is using to defend themselves from Russia's war of conquest.

    Fucker.

    • Yeah, where’s the charges? When’s the pentagon decoupling from his businesses?

      • It's not a secret that SpaceX and Tesla have "disaster" teams that follow and try to patch up his worse tendencies, and SpaceX has been led more by Shotwell for several years now. He really is just the PR guy for SpaceX these days, and I'm sure the Pentagon has made it clear that needs to continue given his actions over the last year.

  • So does this mean that Elon thinks Starlink is responsible for whatever its internet access is used for? If Starlink can manipulate their service to inhibit war time activities, why wouldn't they be responsible for not shutting off access to people or groups facilitating crimes, such as distributing CSAM or drugs? Seems like Elon is admitting that Starlink does have the capability.

  • This story is getting a lot of play, seems like someone in the defense industry is pushing it hard.

    Giving Starlink away for free as a humanitarian effort for the people of Ukraine makes a lot of sense, it's the right thing to do and good PR for Space X.

    Using Starlink for military operations also makes a lot of sense, if you need it, they are building out "Starshield" services for just that purpose but it's not what the current network was designed for and it's hard to get the appropriate licenses in a war zone.

    As for asking for someone to pay for the service: nobody is giving away military hardware for free, it's all on lend-lease agreements that Ukraine will eventually have to repay over time (the UK only recently finished paying their WWII bills to the US on similar agreements).

10 comments