Todd at Science of Sharp mostly did razor sharpening for his early posts. In the last few years he branched into analyzing some of the supersteels used in knives.
I hone my own. My edges are not on par with pro edges I've used but I'm often a few weeks between shaves and I like it a little forgiving on the flesh. I'm not too fussed about billiard ball smooth
I only ever sent one razor out for sharpening, it was for some comedy level sharp from someone using Ken Schwartz sub-micron sprays. Glad I tried it, not for me.
In the first few years I bought maybe ten or more cheap vintage razors from people who seemed to know what they were doing, was a nice way to try different blades and edges.
That brought a chuckle. Ken is no longer with us, but I had many a phone conversation with him about sharpening and about his products. I liked Ken's enthusiasm for freehand sharpening and for making different abrasive products available. We did not always agree so some of those conversations were heated. I don't have any of his sprays but I do have a bunch of CBN and polycrystalline diamond powder (PDP) emulsions. I use them, but agree wholeheartedly that you can do without them.
For someone who is interested and willing to put up with some trial and error, razor edge maintenance is a very approachable skill.
Learning how to properly set a bevel and how to deal with geometry issues takes a lot more time, but people have been shaping tools and weapons by rubbing metal on rocks for a very long time. Most folks can do this.
For someone getting into straights, I suggest getting a pro edge to start with. Unfortunately, many shave-ready edges aren’t.
And for someone who doesn’t want to hone or doesn’t have the time, I suggest using a pasted strop every 15 shaves (or so). Assuming your stropping technique is reasonable, this will significantly extend your edge refresh interval.
For someone getting into straights, I suggest getting a pro edge to start with.
Yeah, this is important advice. I never felt sure my blades were sharp until I had blades honed by Ralf Aust and Brad Maggard to compare to (and later yours, too!)
I don’t want to get into bevel-setting and razor restauration myself.
I think I fall in between. Setting a bevel doesn't scare me, but I don't have the bandwidth to start restoring old blades. That being said, I have a bunch of scales and a couple blades I planned to fit them on, but I never seem to find the time 🙂.
I don’t really want to entrust a straight razor to the postal service.
I actually do own a soldering gun, and that was my original plan, but someone much more skilled in using them convinced me it wouldn’t really work. It’s been many many years since I’ve used one anyway, so it’s probably just as well that I go a different route.
I appreciate the B&B thread, that looks to have all the info I was looking for!