If I haven't played either RDR game, should I start here or play 2 first? It seems like 2 might be a better game and I don't have to worry too much about knowing the story from the first one?
Definitely give the first a shot as it may not be so easy to go back after playing the second. Plus UNDEAD NIGHTMARE is legit a good time. Really wish Rockstar had kept up with DLC at least so we could get a GTA Undead Nightmare.