Here is a comprehensive list of suggestions that have been posted many times before. If your suggestion matches one of these, please make sure that it offers something new or original to every other time it has been proposed, otherwise it will be removed.

If a recent or upcoming update makes an idea more practical or essential than before, then it may also be posted, as long as it adds something NEW to the concept and isn't just a repeat of old ideas that have been done to death.

Bear in mind, most of these suggestions aren’t necessarily "bad". In fact, many of them are objectively good ideas that just have the misfortune of being posted too many times to be considered unique anymore. Always remember that even if an idea is on this list, it can still have a chance to be implemented in some way (crossbows, pandas, scaffolding, coral, and many other features in the game were once FPS list entries too).

“But I can’t read every entry - it’s too long!”

No worries - there’s some handy tools you can use if you want to look for a specific entry.

1. Use the categories (e.g. Blocks, Utility, Mobs). Scroll through the categories that are appropriate for your post, and see if there’s an FPS entry for your idea.

2. Use CTRL+F if you’re on PC. This brings up a prompt that you can use to search for key terms.

3. Perhaps the most elegant method: Go to the #bots-n-spam channel in our Discord, and use Titanium Bot, which is a very useful bot made by u/TitaniumBrain. Use the command .f [keyword] to search both the FPS list.

Give feedback on the list

You can give feedback to the FPS list itself by commenting on this post. Feel free to let us know whenever you like if there's a change or addition to be made, and we'll let you know if it should be added or not.

Hot Topics

This section is reserved for ideas that are unlikely to be frequently suggested for a long period of time, but are being suggested a lot recently, likely due to snapshot hype. As this will constantly be changing, once ideas die down, they will be removed from this section. Alternatively if it seems like the idea will stick around for the long term, it will be added to the main list.

• A way to turn allays into vexes/vexes into allays
• Wardens get stunned by any source of sound, such as jukeboxes, TNT, fireworks, bats, etc.
• “Stealth” enchantment/potion or feather falling/slow falling reduces/cancels player noise, making it harder to be noticed by a warden
• Unique visual effect when spectating a warden
• Wardens being able to burrow
• Wardens being able to climb
• Wardens being able to regenerate health in some way
• Echo versions of existing items, made/upgraded with echo shards
• Adding the cancelled fireflies, whether modified or not

Blocks

• Give any existing common building block in the game (e.g. terracotta, concrete, netherrack, snow, dirt, etc.) a slab/stair/wall/brick/cracked brick/pillar/polished/etc. variant
• Chests/bookshelves/etc. for all wood types (partially implemented with signs, buttons, and pressure plates)
• Furnaces/Stonecutters etc. for all stone types (partially implemented with blackstone buttons/pressure plates/etc.)
• Any stone/cobblestone based items work like the full block does (e.g.: stone stairs/etc. become cobblestone stairs/etc. when mined, cobblestone stairs/etc. become stone stairs/etc. when smelted, stone stairs/etc. stay as stone stairs/etc. when silk touch is used, etc.)
• Add NBT data to certain blocks (only block entities can store NBT information)
• Add any gold or copper version of existing iron blocks (e.g.: hoppers, chains, bars, doors etc.)
• Fake Netherite blocks/any other expensive block (a survival friendly way to use the Netherite/etc. block texture without the high cost)
• Craftable/mine-able End portal blocks
• Blackstone generators
• Add any missing soul fire variants (e.g.: soul fire jack o' lanterns)
• Lava-logged/glass-filled/filler blocks
• Storage block for charcoal
• Glass doors/trapdoors
• Rope/rope blocks/rope ladders (partially implemented via weeping vines/twisted vines and cave vines)
• Rotten flesh blocks
• Ash blocks (most commonly suggested for the Nether)
• Crystal blocks (partially implemented as amethyst crystals)
• Darkstone/any block/item/etc. that cancels out light/produces negative light/etc.
• Lava sponges
• Warped wart and crimson wart, used to craft warped Nether bricks and crimson Nether bricks, respectively, as well as any other common, generic, or obvious uses for them (e.g. a use in potions that acts different from Netherwart, fortresses made of the brick blocks, etc.)
• Magnet/magnet blocks that attract/repel certain items/entities
• Oil (generates underground, highly flammable, makes good fuel, can be sold to villagers etc.)
• A music disc/painting/banner pattern for every update
• Note blocks make a unique sound on amethyst
• Colored light, using colored lamps, stained glass, etc.
• Using Silk Touch on a spawner picks it up
• Icicles, or an ice variant of dripstone
• Clovers related to Luck effect in some way
• Azalea wood
• Re-adding roses and/or cyan roses

Building Improvements and Decoration

Limitations often encourage builders to come up with creative solutions, such as chairs made from stairs or slabs.

• Sideways banners/flags
• Horizontal glass panes/fences/walls/etc.
• Leads can be placed sideways on fences to make "rope fences"
• Custom paintings/drawing paintings
• More banner patterns
• Carpet or snow layers placed over stairs/slabs/walls/etc. changes to fit them exactly
• Carpets can be stacked up when placed similar to snow layers, either with mixed colors or only the same color
• Colored/stained lanterns/redstone lamps/torches etc. (partially implemented with Soul Torches and Soul Fire Lamps, being blue)
• Colored campfire flames/smoke
• Connected textures for certain blocks when placed next to one another (e.g.: glass, slime blocks, honey blocks, etc.)
• Soundproof blocks/certain blocks have varying effects on sound (from blocking it completely to dampening it)
• Ability to rotate blocks in some way (e.g.: a block rotator, a wrench item, etc.)

Player Vanity

• Tabards/surcoats/wearable banners
• Ability to equip any item/block in the helmet slot
• Adding banner patterns to the elytra/beds/armor/etc.
• Ability to dye elytra any color, similar to leather armor
• Any current/future armor can be dyed just like leather armor
• Purely aesthetic/decorative tools/weapons/armor/etc.
• Obtaining capes in any way that isn't already supported
• Witch hats/Villager hats can be obtained and worn

Combat, Armor, Weapons, and Tools

• Daggers or knives (throwable or melee)
• Spears or javelins
• Boomerang (damages mobs/picks up items/flicks levers, etc.)
• Grappling hook (pulls enemies closer, pulls you towards blocks, etc.)
• Explosive arrows
• Slingshots
• Scythes, either as a weapon or a farming implement
• Lances for horseback combat
• Blowguns/darts (just the weapon itself, or they can inflict potion effects like poison and slowness)
• Dynamite/throwable TNT or fire charges/grenades
• Tiered arrows (e.g.: iron/gold/diamond/Netherite/etc. tipped arrows), made through crafting or added as a function for fletching tables
• Tipping arrows with potion effects as a function of the fletching table
• Poison/potion tipped sword
• Different types of swords (long swords, rapiers, broadswords, etc.)
• Different types of bows/crossbows (longbows, compact bows, bows with different materials, etc.)
• Different types of shields/different materials used to craft shields (tower shields, kite shields, Netherite shields, diamond shields, etc.)
• Craft/repair tridents with prismarine related items, etc.
• Craftable chainmail armor (using iron nuggets or otherwise)
• Craftable horse armor or saddles (partially implemented with leather horse armor)
• Any weapon/tool/armor type can be upgraded to the next tier in the smithing table, just like with diamond gear to Netherite gear
• Making armor/weapons/tools out of materials that are out of place or unfit for such things (e.g.: lapis/redstone/emerald/etc. armor/weapons/tools)
• Ability to use various materials in place of sticks for tool handles, either for aesthetics or to provide different stats/abilities (e.g.: bones, blaze rods, etc.)
• Different textures/stats/abilities/etc. for wooden/stone tools based on the wood/stone type used (e.g.: dark oak wooden tools, blackstone tools, etc.)
• "Headshot" --- hitting a player/mob head causes more damage (or generally location specific damage)
• Different tools do more damage to certain mobs than swords do (e.g.: pickaxe does more damage to iron golems/shulkers, shovels do more damage to snow golems, etc.)
• Shield bashing, either as an ability or an enchantment (left click with a shield knocks enemies back, damages them, stuns them, etc.)
• Fishing rods (regular, enchanted, or a new variety) can be used in lava/the Nether
• Pickaxes/shovels/hoes having combat utility
• Ability to insta-mine any block that isn't already insta-mineable, either with a potion/effect, a beacon effect, an enchantment, netherite tools or a new tier of tools, etc.
• Torch arrows, or making spectral arrows emit light

Utility

• Better stair math (output being 6/8, or recipe being 3 blocks instead of 6) (partially implemented with the stonecutter for stone materials)
• Stonecutters cut wood blocks as well as stone, or a separate wood cutter/sawmill/carpentry table for cutting wood
• Stonecutters deal damage when stepped on
• Kilns for smelting clay/terracotta/etc. faster
• "Better furnaces" that smelt everything faster (regular furnaces are not going to be replaced, blast furnaces and smokers are for specific items only so that the furnace remains useful)
• Breaking down crafted items for resources - uncrafting/salvaging table
• Campfires/beacons prevent mob spawning in a large radius
• Campfires scare/ward off hostile mobs
• Smelting rotten flesh gives leather
• Rotten flesh can be used in composters
• Using coal/charcoal to make black/grey dye
• Placing milk/honey/any future liquid in cauldrons
• Text on signs will remain if the sign is silk touched/some way of keeping the text on a sign
• Withered/charred/black bones dropped by Wither Skeletons, craftable into withered bone meal (used to decay/kill/stop the growth of/etc. plants, or make Netherwart grow faster)
• Special chests/gravestones that store items/XP upon death
• A way to disable a work station/prevent a Villager from using a work station block
• Some way to heal snow golems (e.g.: snowballs, blue ice, snowy weather, etc.)
• Combine any existing item with a Netherite ingot in a smithing table to get a Netherite version of the given item, or add various Netherite based items in general (e.g.: Netherite bows, Netherite crossbows, Netherite tridents, Netherite horse armor, Netherite shulker boxes, etc.)
• Additional effects based on the material used in a beacon pyramid/as "fuel" in the beacon (e.g.: Netherite blocks in the pyramid grant fire resistance, increase the range of effect, prevent mob spawns, etc.)
• Craft any stone/cobblestone related items using basalt/andesite/granite/diorite/etc. (e.g.: furnaces, tools, etc.), or use any variant of a given block interchangeably for crafting/etc. (e.g.: soul sand can be smelted into glass, crafted into TNT, etc.) (partially implemented with blackstone blocks)
• Add some method to prevent Piglins/Hoglins/etc. from zombifying in the Overworld, or add some method to cure zombified Piglins/Zoglins/etc.
• Depth meter (displays Y-level, or indicates depth in some way)
• Obtaining white dye from white flowers (e.g. white tulips, etc.) instead of light gray dye
• Glowing ink/dye used to craft glow sticks, coloured lamps, glowing wool/armor/banners etc.
• Replacing gold or iron with copper in crafting recipes (e.g., powered rails crafted with copper)

Redstone

• Pipes/tubes/etc. for transferring items, connecting functional block inventories/GUI's, etc.
• Vertical/ceiling-sticking/wireless/insulated (e.g.: cables, etc.)/underwater redstone
• A way to prevent redstone lines from connecting to one another/parallel redstone lines without repeaters
• "Honey pistons" (e.g.: pistons that stick to honey blocks but not to slime blocks, pistons that aren't affected by quasi-connectivity, as well as multiple other variations on the concept)
• Give any item/block/etc. special functionality in a dispenser
• Redstone lamps light level based on the signal strength provided, or any redstone device being more/less effective based on the signal strength
• Fuses (place gunpowder, light it, slowly burns, one-time redstone use)

Transportation

• Boats with Banners (as sails or otherwise)
• Larger craftable boats/modular boats/ships
• Furnace carts unaffected by turns or elevation
• A way to link minecarts together (e.g.: with chains, leads, etc.)
• Trains of any kind (from linked minecarts to actual trains/train cars/engines)
• Horse-drawn buggy/wagon for transportation or extra storage
• Crimson/Warped boats
• Furnaces/dispensers/droppers/jukeboxes/any other blocks in minecarts/boats

User Interface/GUIs

• Various mechanics when in any GUI (e.g.: ability to see/interact with equipped armor, ability to see and interact with the offhand slot, etc.)
• Add a furnace, crafting table, anvil, etc. GUI to the creative mode inventory
• Some form of a pick-tool key/action, which puts the appropriate tool in the main hand when clicking a block
• Backpacks/satchels/enchantments/etc. for use in expanding the inventory, or directly expand the base inventory itself (shulker boxes and bundles already fulfill this mechanic to an extent)
• Better Book and Quill item (easier formatting/typo fixing/color codes/maps or pictures in books/text selection)
• Colorblind support

Enchantments and Magic

• Magic for players (spells/staffs/wands/runes/etc.)
• "Quickdraw" enchantment for bows
• "Auto-smelt" enchantment (mining ores gets ingots, clay gets bricks)
• "Timber"/"tree-feller"/"vein-miner" enchantment (break a single log/ore, others of the same type around it get auto-mined)
• "Speed"/"swiftness"/"traveler" enchantment on boots/leggings (partially implemented with the Soul Speed enchantment for boots, at least on soul sand and soul soil)
• "Scythe"/"Fertilization"/"Mass Tilling"/"Auto-Plant" enchantment for hoes
• "Ore Vision" / X-ray vision potion/enchantment for tools
• "Reflection/Deflection" enchantment for shields that knocks arrows/fireworks/fireballs back towards attacker
• "True Unbreaking"/"Unbreakable" enchantment for armor/weapons/tools that leaves them in a broken state at 0 durability, like with elytra
• "Decapitator"/"Head Hunter" enchantment (killing mobs gets mob heads/a chance for mobs to drop their head)
• "Lava vision" enchantment/potion, or add a lava vision effect to the fire protection enchantments/etc. (allows the player to see under lava/see better under lava. Partially implemented through the fire resistance effect)
• "Soul Fire Aspect" enchantment (e.g.: Fire Aspect III, Fire Aspect creates blue flames under certain conditions, etc.)
• "Magnetism" enchantment that draws in dropped items/immediately collects items upon mining blocks
• "Lava-Walker" enchantment that turns lava into obsidian or magma when walking on it
• "Anti-Illager" enchantment that does more damage to Illagers/raid mobs (Vindicator, Evoker, Pillager, witch, ravager, vex)
• Invisibility 2 effect/invisibility enchantment (hides armor/weapons/particles/etc.)
• Feather falling enchantment/a new enchantment /etc. prevents crops from being trampled
• Add Curses that are just the opposite of existing enchantments
• Some way to transfer enchantments, or choose specific enchantments (e.g.: a grindstone or new block that takes enchantments from armor/weapons/tools and puts them onto books).
• Enchantments have environmental effects on items (e.g.: Fire protection prevents an item from burning in lava or makes it drain durability instead, etc.)
• Enchantments have unique designs/textures for each book/tool/armor piece (thorns is spiky, frost-walker has ice crystals, etc.)
• Magic protection enchantment (protects players from potions, other enchantments, guardian beams, evocation fangs, etc.)
• Enchantment for weapons that makes them unable to harm pets/golems/etc.

Potions and Brewing

• Enchant empty/water bottle to get bottle o' enchanting/collecting XP with bottles gives you bottles o’ enchanting/some way to store XP (somewhat implemented with Sculk)
• Use the cauldron to brew potions
• Splash bonemeal/plant growth potion, AoE bonemeal
• Splash potions of milk (clear potion effects)
• Adding frog legs for brewing potions of leaping, and make rabbit's foot brew potions of luck
• Make any existing effect that is not already a potion into a brewable potion (wither, luck, haste, glowing, resistance, etc.)
• Using thick or mundane potions as a base (these are specifically designed not to have any use at this stage in the development of the game)

Food and Edibles

• Chocolate or chocolate milk/cake (cocoa beans + milk/cake)
• Cook eggs to get scrambled eggs/boiled egg/fried egg/omelette
• Cake slices/cake movable after placing
• Apple/berry pie
• Oranges and apple/orange juice
• Bananas generate in jungles
• Sandwiches
• Cheese
• Nether Stew, a soup using Nether fungi
• Corn crops for villages/farms
• Bake bread with a furnace for baked bread/toast, or bread requires a furnace to make
• Different food takes different times to consume (partially implemented with dried kelp) (potentially upcoming via liquid foods being faster to consume than solid food, as of Combat Test 8c)
• Placeable milk/honey/any future liquid (like water or lava)
• Eating porkchops or rotten flesh in front of Piglins angers them
• Glow berries granting Glowing
• Golden variants of existing food

World Generation

• Redwood Trees
• Oasis biome in deserts (palm trees, water pool, vegetation, greener grass, etc.)
• Villages for more biomes (e.g.: swamps, jungles, mountains, underground, Nether, End, etc.)
• Colored lava
• Cold biomes in the Nether, or any other type of climate/biome/etc. that is entirely unfit for the Nether's environment
• Campsite structures (for Villagers, Wandering Traders, Pillagers, Piglins, or undead mobs)
• Sponges generate in coral reefs
• Ruby, sapphire, tin, titanium, etc. ore: Ores that do not impact gameplay in a meaningful way are not worth adding. (Somewhat "implemented" with copper)
• Enderite/Endite ore for the End (resistant to the Void in some way, is stronger than diamond/netherite, found under end islands, etc.)
• Various different metal alloys, steel, pig iron, etc.
• Add cubic chunks
• Dream/imaginary dimension, accessible through sleeping, potions or portals
• Suggesting to take features from one dimension and adding it to any of the others (e.g.: adding coal/iron/diamond ores to the Nether/End, adding Overworld mobs to those dimensions, adding water to the Nether, etc.)
• Overworld/Nether/End reset options
• Add an option or gamerule to start a world in the Nether
• One dimension can spread/leak/etc. into another dimension (partially implemented via ruined Nether portals)
• Superflat worlds also generate superflat Nethers/ends, or separate options for a superflat Nether/End
• End islands generate at different heights
• Better/more realistic river generation; rivers start at high altitudes; rivers form waterfalls

Environment and Weather

• Seasons
• Auroras/Northern Lights in Cold Biomes
• Lava rain/lava floods in the Nether
• Adding Overworld weather (lightning storms, rain, etc.) to the Nether
• Lightning strikes cause sand/red sand/soul sand to turn into glass
• More weather conditions (e.g.: blizzards, sandstorms, hail, fog, etc.)
• Make weather regional rather than global/add a command/option to change it
• Shooting stars

Mobs and Mob Behaviors

• Any real life animal (birds, monkeys, bears, snakes, rats, butterflies, etc.), without including any original behaviour/characteristics
• Common/unoriginal boss ideas (queen bee/spider, Illager boss, Nether fortress boss, etc.)
• Common/overdone Villager profession ideas (e.g.: Miner, lumberjack, builder, bee keeper, musician, artist, firework sellers, etc.)
• More animal skins/breeds/variants (different dog breeds are among the most common in this category)
• Armor for pets/animals (dogs/cats/parrots/etc.)
• "Wandering mode" for pets
• The ability to pet or play fetch with dogs/cats/parrots/etc.
• Biome/dimension-dependent mob skins or variations
• Pirate mobs, whether they be undead or Illagers
• Elves/dwarves/orcs/goblins/ogres
• More golems (gold, ice, stone, End, Netherite, etc.)
• Ghast nests/baby ghasts
• Make zombies randomly have a skin based on the other default skins
• Creepers blend into biome/surroundings, chameleon creepers
• Spiders flip their bodies vertically to climb walls
• Mobs transform into other mobs when struck by lightning, change behavior, or change existing transformations (e.g.: pigs turn into something other than zombified Piglins when struck by lightning)
• Phantoms spawn in The End
• Zombies attack Illagers/Illager zombies
• Cave spiders spawning outside of mineshafts
• Endermen's eyes turn green after defeating the ender dragon, and/or they become passive somehow
• Add more mob heads/any new mob heads
• Slimes can reform/combine/merge back into larger slimes
• Miner zombies/zombies with pickaxes
• Clerics using healing potions to heal other Villagers, and blacksmiths using iron ingots to heal iron golems
• Cartographers/Wandering Traders/etc. sell maps to mushroom island biomes/other rare biomes/structures
• Infiltrator/spy/disguised Illager (an Illager disguised as a Villager, disrupts a village and/or attacks when revealed/attempting to trade)
• Bring back the old Zombie Pigman model in some way (e.g. as a separate mob, through resource packs, naming them with nametags, etc.)
• Rename Zombified Piglins to Zombie Piglins or Ziglins
• Pigs/Piglins/any pig related mob dances to the pigstep music disc
• Piglins offer/barter/drop maps to Nether structures (Bastions, fortresses, etc.)
• Elder guardians/any other mini boss should have their own boss bars/health bars
• Wandering traders [should] sell X (adding any new items to it's trade pool to make it more useful or for whatever reason)
• Dragon taming
• Undead mobs regenerate from Poison and/or take damage over time from Regeneration
• Removing phantoms
• Husks drop sand

Gameplay Mechanics

• Fall damage based on block you land on (partially implemented with hay bales, honey blocks and beds)
• Arrows/Tridents/falling anvils/gliding with an elytra/etc. will shatter glass
• Players can drop their head on certain death conditions
• A method to revive pets (e.g.: totem of undying, pet collar, pet bed, etc.)
• Dragon Egg can be hatched (baby ride-able dragon)
• Dragon Egg for every dragon killed, rather than just the first
• Negative beacon effects (weakness, jump height reduction, slower regeneration, etc.)
• More music discs/custom music discs/recorder block to record sounds/music
• Flying over a campfire with an elytra causes lift/pushes the player up into the air
• Swimming in lava using Netherite armor or fire resistance potions
• Give rarer items (such as Netherite, the Dragon Egg, the Heart of the Sea, etc.) more unique properties than they already have (such as an increased despawn time limit, immunity to cacti, etc.)
• Chains can be used to hold up gravity affected blocks/keep them from falling
• Chains stick together, and pulling one pulls any connected chains as well
• Furnaces give more than one item of output per input item (e.g.: the amount of iron/gold nuggets from smelting armor is based on the durability of the armor)
• Furnaces smelt items faster in the Nether, or faster based on the fuel used, or items can be smelted/cooked just from being in the Nether
• Placing gunpowder or TNT in furnaces cause them to explode
• Sleeping causes all crops/furnaces/potions/etc. to finish/speed up growing/cooking/brewing/etc.
• Wearing a zombie head causes Villagers to flee/panic, causes iron golems to attack the player, etc.
• End Anchor/Respawn Anchor working in the End, or some other way of respawning in the End
• Various mob interactions with music discs 11 and 13 (e.g.: passive or other mobs run away from the music, Illagers dance to them, etc.) (partially rejected for parrots, as they are designed to dance to all music discs)
• Special nametags/potions can silence/quiet down mobs (or some other form of "silence"/sound reduction mechanic that silences/reduces the sound of blocks and mobs)
• Two players can ride on horses/multiplayer horse riding
• Shearing chickens/parrots gives feathers
• Copper oxidation is affected when in the End
• Tinted glass stops/redirects/affects beacon beams
• Any new beacon effect (e.g. night vision)
• Smelting raw ore blocks
• Optimization/Bugfix Update
• Reimplementing pre-1.9 combat
• Mobs set on fire by soul fire burn blue
• Setting to change how often music is played, and/or which songs are played

Map-Making and Commands

• A specific block/item for map makers to re-model/re-texture
• Allow custom models/textures based on new/existing NBT data (e.g.: a Model tag) or unused damage values (Partially implemented via CustomModelData])
• Command to change/test biomes (possible through advancements/predicates for testing biomes)
• Ability to set mobGriefing/mobSpawning/etc. for each mob/etc., either as separate gamerules for each one, or through additional parameters to the existing gamerules
• Selector (argument) for hostile, neutral, passive, tameable, etc. mobs (e.g.: @h, @e[kind=hostile])(Partially implemented via the https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Tag#Entity_Types)
• Having a gamerule for something very minor/any small inconvenience/something that can already be easily and reasonably prevented

Account

• Bedrock worlds sync across accounts/platforms, or some way to transfer Bedrock worlds between accounts/platforms