Path of Night as someone who is obsessed with Vampire: the Masquerade, who has been all-in on trying to find a serious horror live-play. The cast does a wonderful job selling the universe. All the meta-plot is gracefully woven in and both the narrative and players do a great job of putting you somewhere dark and frightening. Honestly? The production is so high quality that you could be forgiven thinking it could be White Wolf RPG’s flagship podcast, as Critical Role has been to D&D. Killer music too.
Find the Path Podcast is the best I've found, full stop. There are still laughs, but they aren't the cheap one liners so nauseatingly prevalent in so many other actual play podcasts I've tried. Instead the focus is on the story, characters, and world around them.
Truly a unique and wonderful experience.
It's Pathfinder 1e and 2e. Production value is very high generally. Audiophile quality these days, though even in the first few episodes the audio is done well.
They do a lot of sketch comedy based around games on their main channel, especially about mmos with their "Epic NPC man" series, and they used the same universe from their skits as the setting for their D&D games, which has been awesome.
They're super fun to watch and their DM is amazing as well. They even do little skits dressed as their characters in every episode, about any interesting moments from their table session!
I also like how they release episodes in weekly, bite sized, edited 30min videos, which i find much easier to consume than your average 3+ hours unedited dnd podcast.
It is truly a gem and i've no idea how they're not more popular.