Offset speed limit signs: am I mapping this correctly?
Offset speed limit signs: am I mapping this correctly?
I have recently got into mapping traffic signs and speed limits where I can, but I realised I don't know what to do when mapping differing speed limit signs that are offset from each other. It's a transition from a 50km/h zone to a 60km/h zone but the signs are offset by 65m, making a sort of "no-mans land" in-between. I plan to map it with the in-between zone tagged with separate maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward tags. I assume it should be done this way because as a driver on the ground I would follow the speed limit signs on my side of the road as I passed them, having no knowledge of the reverse sign.
I guess I'm wondering if this is a logical way to map this?
I plan to map it with the in-between zone tagged with separate maxspeed:forward and maxspeed:backward tags.
Maybe it would be better to use the lower speed limit in the "no-man's land", since it would be unfortunate to be driving too fast while thinking one is folliwing speed limit. I assume it's kind of ambigous what the allowed speed limit is?
For mapping, I agree with your logic. I just think we should err on the side of causion when things are ambigous.
I think what he means is, from the point of the driver driving from the 50 to the 60 area:
You drive fifty, then you pass a sign pointed away from you (towards oncomming traffic) saying 50. 65m further, you pass a sign pointed at you saying 60.
In that case I would say the speedlimit is just different for that 65m stretch of road, based on the direction of travel. The speedlimit changes at the 50 sign if driving from 60 to 50, and at the 60 sign if driving from 50 to 60.
If I misunderstood, and this what OP meant, then I agree with your reasoning and solution.
Fair point! Better safe than sorry. On the other hand, drivers 'round here will go 20 over no matter what I designate it as lol. Kidding... kinda.
Couldn't you just create dedicated tags for the individual directions of the lanes? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:maxspeed mentions this in the Lanes section.
The speed limit need not be the same for each direction of travel. The speed limit changes at the sign. There is no expectation that the signs be at the same road stationing for opposing traffic. If the open street map database can't handle that appropriately, then there is no correct way to map this situation.
@sven @openstreetmap I think the tagging you're showing *should* be fine, but as I think the
:forwardandbackwardtags aren't as widely supported I'd put the lower speed as a genericmaxspeedfor that bit of road as well. That way simple software will default to the lower limit and more sophisticated software will use the correct one.That's a good point! Keeping compatibility is important.
Interesting. I just found this instruction. I'm guessing you already did too. (Source)
For speed limits depending on the way direction, see maxspeed:forward=*.So I would say, map that section of road with forward/backward speeds. Also, the signs should be independent nodes.
The position of the actual speed limit signs can be added as nodes beside the road/railway/waterway