From Criterion to Arrow: the cult of movie collecting
From Criterion to Arrow: the cult of movie collecting
In the streaming age, collecting physical media, such as boutique Blu-Rays by the likes of Criterion, Arrow and BFI is more important than ever.
Yet, the popularity of boutique Blu-Rays doesn’t seem to be waning, a sign that the interest in physical media is still going strong. The Criterion Collection is easily the biggest specialist company making Blu-Rays, having first released a series of DVDs in 1998. In 2008, they released their first Blu-Ray, Chungking Express, marking the start of several thousand high-quality editions released by the company, which they consider the finest pieces of cinema.
Criterion’s appeal resides in its attention to detail and consideration for dedicated film fans, filling every release with special features that are actually worth watching or reading, like short films, exclusive interviews, essays, and audio commentary. Each film comes with gorgeous artwork and sometimes even a poster inside, making the price tag (a single film is typically between £15 and £23) much more worth it. Additionally, Criterion takes great pride in restoring films to their original glory, with one of the most striking examples being their restoration of Jacques Demy’s The Umbrellas of Cherbourg. The company also offers boxsets for prestigious directors, like Agnes Varda, Ingmar Bergman and Wong Kar-wai, as well as film series, like the Before trilogy and Eric Rohmer’s Six Moral Tales.
Evidently, film fans can trust Criterion to deliver high-quality editions of their favourite pictures, with the company ensuring that beloved classics and newer releases all get special treatment. With frequent sale seasons allowing buyers to bulk buy some of their most-wanted titles for a more reasonable price, it’s rare you’ll meet a self-confessed cinephile who doesn’t own at least a few Criterions.
...
They’re not the only company releasing collector’s editions, though. Arrow Films, an independent British distributor, offers some of the greatest cult and horror films, complete with a variety of special features, carefully designed artwork, and high-quality Blu-Ray transfers. BFI also provides an impressive collection, focusing on niches such as kitchen sink dramas, forgotten British gems, documentaries, and other acclaimed classics. Another notable company is Eureka, which specialises in films by directors they consider masters of cinema.
Each of these companies taps into a niche to attract customers, whether that be horror or foreign cinema, or in the case of Shameless Screen Entertainment, “carefully picked vile, evil, gore-soaked, demented, disturbing [and] deranged” movies. While specialist companies have existed for a while, like Tartan, which stopped selling its DVDs in 2008, the landscape is now saturated with streaming services all competing to be the best, which you would think might make it harder for these companies to thrive. Yet, it seems as though film fans are keeping physical media alive for now, with many people still wanting to own copies of their favourite films without worrying about a streaming service removing them.
...
Collecting Criterions or other special edition Blu-Rays is the kind of hobby that keeps paying for itself – you can resell them for a decent price, watch them endless times, and access content, like shorts and essays, that you most likely can’t find for free anywhere else. We need physical media to survive in the internet age, and thanks to these companies and the passionate cinephiles who buy their Blu-Rays, hope is not yet lost.
You're viewing a single thread.
Not sure if this is the right place for this but… does anyone have an opinion on the best BD version of The Thing? I see that there’s an Arrow, Shout, and a 4k version. While 4k UHD sounds really tempting I hear the color and sound might be kind of off compared to the others. Any thoughts out there?
You are perfectly welcome to start a new thread but as The Thing is probably my favourite film, I'll jump in.
I did do my research into it before buying the Blu-ray and there seems no definitive answer. I now own the Arrow 4k steelbook and I am perfectly happy with it.
However, you will probably want to look at comparisons between the releases, like spoRV - I've heard people don't like the 4k because it is too "warm" and prefer Arrow's BD but you can see that is far too blue. There's also a comparison between the UHD and HD Universal releases here which shows how much brighter the 4k is. The general feeling seems to be that the 4k picture looks great but the sound might be off.
One of the issues is often that we get used to the version we owned a long time and watched the Hell out of so you could get a restoration to how it is on film and it might feel off. So this could all come down to personal taste.
Out of the comparison shots in that first link I’d say the Shout!-version looks the most natural, but like you say it may just be the most similar to how I’ve watched it in the past