You're viewing a single thread.
Not how it works though. It might alleviate pain and improve your perception of your well-being, but it won't heal you
Nope, the placebo effect can have physical effects and be genuinely curative. The level to which this is the case is highly variable from patient to patient, but it is inaccurate to say that is limited to improving sensation and perception of illness. Not to mention, in many cases the malady being treated is one of perception, for example, in pain management. And alleviating pain in itself has downstream positive effects on disease progression and patient QOL.
Actual chronic pain sufferer here. If I had a dollar every time placebo and positive thinking was prescribed to me, I would have enough to maybe hire a doctor who won't systemically downplay or dismiss my pain because of my age and gender.
I think he's saying that although it's a treatment, it is not a cure.
It seems to me you are actually agreeing with him.
The thing here is that some medicine doesn't really heal either. Paracetamol is just a pain suppressant, and ibuprofen partially suppresses it while accelerating blood flow and thus reducing inflammation, which is why it's used for sore throat, to avoid more friction and let the throat heal by itself.
Aleviating pain is sometimes what your body needs to start focusing on healing itself. It's not a miracle but it works when it does.
Say8ng that placebo effect doesn't heal you isn't really that revealing, plenty medicine doesn't either and that's okay, that's not their objective.
You're right, those thing are treatments, not cures.
It's nice that we all agree.
My random conjure if anyone cares:
I see it like many 'real' medicines that alleviate symptoms. Sometimes the symptoms are the ones causing the issues, EX. a fever to kill germs can kill braincells. But like any medicine that alleviates symptoms, it can also hide problems. So I see it as a case by case thing.Absolutely not true, it has zero physical effect on the body.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FL96to_4NYU Here, for more informationI'm going to trust multiple peer-reviewed medical studies over a youtube talk with under 600 views.
Specially when it's on a channel branding itself as being skeptical towards science.
EDIT: On a closer look it's straight up just one of those conspiracy theory channels and organizations that present itself as actual science.
And here's a study if someone wants to look at actual science regarding the placebo effect:
QED is actually the opposite of a conspiracy theory channel or organisation. They're very pro science and critical thinking, and spend a lot of time debunking conspiracy theories and pseudo-science.
I've got no skin in the debate in this thread, I didn't watch the actual video and have no opinion on the validity of what you or the other posters are saying, I'm just pointing out that I think that you're wrong to dismiss the channel as a source, even if you disagree with the claims made in that specific video.
on a channel branding itself as being skeptical towards science.
You may have misread - its description says it is a "science and skepticism event". Not skeptical of science.
I'm with you, otherwise.
I hope you do, because no good peer-reviewed studies ever produced the results you are talking about. I urge you to show me which ones you are talking about.
And you should learn to look closer. Maybe get more that a couple of words out of headline, you know, how scientificly minded people are suppose to be.You are literally spouting out of your ass. There are multiple peer reviewed papers which show how the body can regenerate itself through placebo effect.
It’s real and verified just like grass. Go touch some. You are way out of your depth here.
Then show me. I don't want to derail you, so show me the best one you think of and let's analyze it.
Go ahead and scroll up and see the studies already provided to you. You are a colossal waste of time.
I like your style, perogi boi.
Says the guy who didn't even read the linked study
Here is an alternative Piped link(s): https://piped.video/watch?v=FL96to_4NYU
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source, check me out at GitHub.
What if the malady is mere pain and inadequate well-being perception?
Semantics, I guess, but it says "disease" in the meme, does that really constitute a disease?
The disease of a corrupted mind, burn the heretic.