Hmmm i ruminated a lot on this one but I'd pick "Play your favorite Otome game for the first time again", except not to play a "favorite" but to play the Vampire Knight otome game for DS again, which is an incredibly entertaining train wreck.
It vaguely follows the manga's plot and covers about the same arcs as the first season of the anime, except that it's turned the narrative into a reverse-harem and inserted fever-dream like filler arcs (like the protagonist dreaming up an entire beach-episode??) There were also a bunch of mini games, one of which had you literally stalking your love interest of choice.
I chose to go for a non-canon route for my only run so far, the love interest (Aidou Hanabusa) of which was originally obsessed with one of the canon love interests instead of the heroine. I failed to seduce him and he recruited me into the fanclub instead. I cried laughing when I got to the end.
On top of that the protagonist is just very.. juvenile, which I really dislike, but all of the LIs adore her for her weird antics :/
It's just...hilariously bad, but it has very high production value. It's even fully voiced!
I'm a sucker for things that are so bad they're funny, and I also love drooling over high production value items. Absolutely need to step on trying to English patch it.