Can I refuse MS Authenticator?
Can I refuse MS Authenticator?
So my company decided to migrate office suite and email etc to Microsoft365. Whatever. But for 2FA login they decided to disable the option to choose "any authenticator" and force Microsoft Authenticator on the (private) phones of both employees and volunteers. Is there any valid reason why they would do this, like it's demonstrably safer? Or is this a battle I can pick to shield myself a little from MS?
You're viewing a single thread.
In my case they didn't disable the option to use any authenticator for 2FA.
So I just use another one.
I don't see why forcing MS Authenticator will be better than any other authenticator.
The person who forces it is for sure not a security expert.
It will be easier to hackers to hack 2FA when they know what the authenticator app is, versus hundreds of different authenticator clients.
I'm also not a fan of MS spyware.
But in defence of the MS authenticator, the 2FA prompts it sends are very convenient, how they pop up and ask for the number displayed on screen, its definitely more secure than just the one time code.
Plus it also shows what phone the user is using when they install and configure the authenticator app, this is also very useful if you suddenly see the user accessing their mail or one drive from another mobile device.
It will be easier to hackers to hack 2FA when they know what the authenticator app is, versus hundreds of different authenticator clients.
Security through obscurity is not security.
Additionally, any method that generates a code locally that needs to match the server will not be secure if you can extract the key used locally. Yes you can argue that more users makes a juicier target, but I’d argue that Microsoft has the resources spend reducing the chance of an exploit and the resources to fix it fairly quickly. Much more so than any brand new team.
The default authentication option for the company I work for is that a code is displayed in the screen of the device I’m logging into AND a push notification is sent to the Authenticator app, the app then prompts me to enter the code from authenticating device. To break that you’d need the username, password, a clone of the phone/device used to authenticate (or the original), and the user’s PIN for that device (MS Authenticator requires this to complete the authentication.)
Yes MS Authentication services do sometimes go down, and yea it can impact my ability to work
I am by no means a MS fanatic, but I’d trust them for mission critical authentication over something like Authy.